CARNIVORE
Truths biology can support1. Protein density and leucine are trivially easy
Muscle protein synthesis is sensitive to essential amino acid profile and leucine per meal (~2–3 g threshold for many adults). Animal proteins are complete, dense, and low-volume.
Evidence: Strong mechanistic + consistent intervention data on protein quantity and lean mass.
2. Ultraprocessed food drops to ~zero
Most carnivore protocols eliminate chips, soda, and industrial snack matrices by construction. That alone explains a chunk of real-world transformation stories — not secret cow magic.
Evidence: Strong for UPF reduction; attribution to "only meat" is overstated.
3. Satiety per calorie can rise
Protein is the most satiating macronutrient per calorie. Fat slows gastric emptying. Many adherents spontaneously eat less without calorie counting.
Evidence: Moderate-strong for protein-induced satiety; individual response varies.
4. Elimination can surface intolerances
Strict carnivore is an n=1 elimination probe. Some people feel better when gluten, lactose, or specific FODMAPs disappear.
Evidence: Mechanistic + anecdote-heavy; useful heuristic, not population doctrine.
5. Heme iron and B12 are non-issues
Carnivore sidesteps the two micronutrients vegans must engineer. That's biology, not morality.
Evidence: Strong.
CARNIVORE
Wrongs and oversells1. "Plants are toxic — therefore optimal"
Plants contain phytochemicals and fiber with documented effects on gut microbiome SCFA production and satiety signaling. Zero plants for life is a tradeoff, not a free upgrade.
Evidence: Strong that fiber matters; weak that total plant elimination is long-term optimal for all.
2. LDL hand-waving is not science
Some adherents see LDL-C rise on high saturated fat. ApoB matters for cardiovascular risk over decades. "My uncle ate steak till 90" is anecdote, not ledger.
Evidence: Strong epidemiology + mechanistic; contested magnitude per individual.
3. Constipation and microbiome narrowing
Low fiber → slower transit for many. Microbiome diversity often drops on extreme animal-only patterns. Colorectal health is a decades question.
Evidence: Moderate for microbiome shifts; long-term endpoints need decades.
4. "Fixes autoimmune everything"
Autoimmune disease is heterogeneous. Some patients improve on elimination diets; many do not. Case reports ≠ cured population.
Evidence: Anecdote-heavy; some clinical interest, no blanket proof.
5. Social and adherence cliff
Biology includes behavior. Carnivore at restaurants, family tables, and travel is expensive socially. Diets people quit don't have outcomes.
Evidence: Behavioral — underrated, real.
VEGAN
Truths biology can support1. Fiber feeds the colon
Gut bacteria ferment fiber → butyrate and other SCFAs. That pathway supports gut barrier integrity and metabolic signaling.
Evidence: Strong mechanistic + epidemiology.
2. Cardiometabolic profile can improve
Whole-food vegan patterns often show lower LDL and better blood pressure — when ultraprocessed vegan products are avoided.
Evidence: Moderate-strong for whole-food plant-predominant patterns.
3. High-volume eating for cuts
Plants are low calorie density. A lifter in a cut can fill the stomach while holding protein if planned.
Evidence: Moderate for satiety/volume; protein must be engineered.
4. Adequate protein is possible — engineered
Soy, legumes, seitan, blended plant proteins — leucine threshold still applies. Two hundred grams of broccoli is not two hundred grams of protein.
Evidence: Strong that protein quality/density matters.
5. B12 supplementation is correct biology
Cyanocobalamin or methylcobalamin replaces a supply humans historically got from animal foods or fortification. Moral framing is irrelevant.
Evidence: Strong.
VEGAN
Wrongs and oversells1. "Plants have all the protein" — without math
Incomplete amino acid profiles mean you need combinations and often concentrates to hit lifter targets.
Evidence: Strong on completeness; lifter failure mode is common.
2. Iron and zinc — bioavailability is lower
Non-heme iron absorption is inhibited by phytates and enhanced by vitamin C. Status labs matter for menstruating athletes.
Evidence: Strong mechanistic.
3. Ultraprocessed vegan is still UPF
Vegan burgers, cookies, and oils can be hyperpalatable industrial matrices. Biology logs calories and insulin dynamics, not ethics on the label.
Evidence: Strong — same UPF rules apply.
4. "Soy feminizes men"
At typical dietary soy isoflavone intake, feminization claims lack robust human evidence in euthyroid men.
Evidence: Moderate — normal intakes generally fine.
5. ALA → EPA/DHA conversion is inefficient
Flax is not fish. Algal DHA/EPA supplementation is often the rational vegan biology play.
Evidence: Strong on conversion inefficiency.
WHAT BIOLOGY LOGS
Most evidence for long-lived, strong humans sits in a band:
- Adequate protein (animal and/or engineered plant)
- Mostly whole foods
- Enough fiber for gut function
- Micronutrients covered (B12, iron, D, omega-3 as needed)
- Calories matched to goal
- Adherence you can keep past month three
Carnivore and vegan are extreme anchors that teach tradeoffs. The middle is not "weak" — it's where most measurable outcomes cluster when execution is honest.
STOIC REP FOR NUTRITION
| Yours | Not yours |
|---|---|
| Protein grams per day | What a tribe claims on Reels |
| Sleep, steps, sessions | Whether strangers approve your plate |
| Labs you order with a clinician | Viral before/after with no data |
| Adherence past 90 days | Perfect diet fantasy |
Virtue doesn't reset on Monday. Your gut microbiome doesn't either — it responds to what you repeat.
MEMBERSHIP GETS NEXT
Full food math guides, workout plans, weekly stories, and recovery basics — paid gym culture without supplement-bro energy. €12/mo unlocks the full library.
START MEMBERSHIP — €12/MO Stripe · cancel anytime · Try food calculator free